Skip to content

fix: drop signed attributes PAdES forbids from CAdES signatures - #105

Merged
Mythie merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
fix/pades-forbidden-signed-attrs
Oct 16, 2026
Merged

Mythie merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
fix/pades-forbidden-signed-attrs

Conversation

@Mythie

@Mythie Mythie commented Oct 16, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

ETSI EN 319 142-1 Table 1 forbids signing-time in PAdES
baseline signatures (/M carries the claimed time), and
clause 6.3 excludes cms-algorithm-protection.

adbe.pkcs7.detached keeps both.

ETSI EN 319 142-1 Table 1 forbids signing-time in PAdES
baseline signatures (/M carries the claimed time), and
clause 6.3 excludes cms-algorithm-protection.

adbe.pkcs7.detached keeps both.
@vercel

vercel Bot commented Oct 16, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

The latest updates on your projects. Learn more about Vercel for GitHub.

Project Deployment Actions Updated
core Ready Ready Preview Oct 16, 2026 5:32am UTC

@github-actions

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Benchmark Results

Comparison

Load PDF

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
libpdf 16.37ms 25.51ms ±4.1% 31
pdf-lib 197.08ms 199.07ms ±0.6% 10
@cantoo/pdf-lib 196.03ms 202.17ms ±1.0% 10

Create blank PDF

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
libpdf 48μs 96μs ±1.9% 10503
pdf-lib 232μs 1.09ms ±3.0% 2154
@cantoo/pdf-lib 246μs 1.28ms ±3.0% 2036

Add 10 pages

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
libpdf 86μs 155μs ±0.8% 5797
pdf-lib 325μs 1.53ms ±3.2% 1538
@cantoo/pdf-lib 302μs 1.82ms ±3.8% 1654

Draw 50 rectangles

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
libpdf 275μs 721μs ±1.5% 1820
pdf-lib 1.14ms 4.56ms ±6.7% 438
@cantoo/pdf-lib 1.29ms 3.50ms ±4.8% 388

Load and save PDF

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
libpdf 15.89ms 18.20ms ±1.4% 32
pdf-lib 287.19ms 301.00ms ±1.5% 10
@cantoo/pdf-lib 462.82ms 476.48ms ±1.4% 10

Load, modify, and save PDF

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
libpdf 296.25ms 316.82ms ±2.0% 10
pdf-lib 286.50ms 300.96ms ±1.6% 10
@cantoo/pdf-lib 470.80ms 492.65ms ±1.8% 10

Extract single page from 100-page PDF

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
libpdf 2.87ms 3.53ms ±1.0% 175
pdf-lib 8.09ms 9.62ms ±1.3% 62
@cantoo/pdf-lib 8.48ms 10.18ms ±2.0% 59

Split 100-page PDF into single-page PDFs

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
libpdf 30.17ms 35.40ms ±2.8% 17
pdf-lib 61.99ms 68.60ms ±3.8% 9
@cantoo/pdf-lib 70.81ms 96.64ms ±12.8% 8

Split 2000-page PDF into single-page PDFs (0.9MB)

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
libpdf 573.50ms 573.50ms ±0.0% 1
pdf-lib 1.14s 1.14s ±0.0% 1
@cantoo/pdf-lib 1.30s 1.30s ±0.0% 1

Copy 10 pages between documents

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
libpdf 3.63ms 4.55ms ±1.2% 138
pdf-lib 10.74ms 12.45ms ±1.5% 47
@cantoo/pdf-lib 12.09ms 13.22ms ±1.3% 42

Merge 2 x 100-page PDFs

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
libpdf 12.28ms 13.35ms ±1.5% 41
pdf-lib 48.73ms 49.75ms ±0.7% 11
@cantoo/pdf-lib 58.59ms 60.01ms ±0.8% 9

Fill FINTRAC form fields

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
libpdf 17.63ms 24.07ms ±4.6% 29
pdf-lib 25.31ms 37.44ms ±5.9% 20
@cantoo/pdf-lib 25.57ms 36.82ms ±6.0% 20

Fill and flatten FINTRAC form

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
libpdf 14.71ms 19.91ms ±3.3% 34
pdf-lib FAILED - - 0
@cantoo/pdf-lib 27.71ms 34.34ms ±3.9% 19
Copying

Copy pages between documents

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
copy 1 page 782μs 1.51ms ±2.0% 640
copy 10 pages from 100-page PDF 3.46ms 4.42ms ±1.5% 145
copy all 100 pages 5.82ms 6.65ms ±1.1% 86

Duplicate pages within same document

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
duplicate page 0 746μs 1.20ms ±1.0% 671
duplicate all pages (double the document) 758μs 1.26ms ±1.2% 660

Merge PDFs

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
merge 2 small PDFs 1.19ms 2.01ms ±1.4% 422
merge 10 small PDFs 5.95ms 7.09ms ±1.3% 85
merge 2 x 100-page PDFs 11.55ms 12.79ms ±1.3% 44
Drawing

benchmarks/drawing.bench.ts

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
draw 100 rectangles 511μs 1.15ms ±2.6% 978
draw 100 circles 786μs 1.53ms ±1.7% 636
draw 100 lines 460μs 1.05ms ±1.6% 1088
draw 100 text lines (standard font) 1.29ms 2.12ms ±1.6% 387
create 10 pages with mixed content 1.19ms 2.18ms ±1.9% 419
Forms

benchmarks/forms.bench.ts

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
get form fields 2.40ms 4.29ms ±2.7% 209
fill text fields 9.55ms 13.11ms ±3.9% 53
read field values 2.26ms 4.19ms ±2.6% 222
flatten form 6.53ms 7.74ms ±1.4% 77
Loading

benchmarks/loading.bench.ts

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
load small PDF (888B) 41μs 88μs ±2.2% 12168
load medium PDF (19KB) 66μs 91μs ±0.5% 7587
load form PDF (116KB) 942μs 1.57ms ±1.2% 531
load heavy PDF (2.0MB) 15.46ms 21.63ms ±2.9% 33
Saving

benchmarks/saving.bench.ts

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
save unmodified (19KB) 75μs 204μs ±1.6% 6673
save with modifications (19KB) 575μs 1.10ms ±1.3% 870
incremental save (19KB) 109μs 270μs ±1.0% 4593
save heavy PDF (2.0MB) 14.77ms 16.31ms ±1.5% 34
incremental save heavy PDF (2.0MB) 15.67ms 17.68ms ±1.6% 32
Splitting

Extract single page

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
extractPages (1 page from small PDF) 797μs 1.57ms ±2.1% 628
extractPages (1 page from 100-page PDF) 2.68ms 3.38ms ±1.2% 187
extractPages (1 page from 2000-page PDF) 42.55ms 49.91ms ±3.6% 12

Split into single-page PDFs

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
split 100-page PDF (0.1MB) 29.74ms 33.33ms ±2.7% 17
split 2000-page PDF (0.9MB) 533.49ms 533.49ms ±0.0% 1

Batch page extraction

Benchmark Mean p99 RME Samples
extract first 10 pages from 2000-page PDF 43.38ms 45.96ms ±1.8% 12
extract first 100 pages from 2000-page PDF 46.30ms 48.20ms ±1.5% 11
extract every 10th page from 2000-page PDF (200 pages) 50.80ms 59.80ms ±4.6% 10
Environment
  • Runner: Linux (X64)
  • Runtime: Bun 1.4.3
  • Libraries: @libpdf/core 0.5.2 (this repo), pdf-lib 1.17.1, @cantoo/pdf-lib 2.9.1

Results are machine-dependent.

@Mythie
Mythie merged commit d0d4926 into main Oct 16, 2026
6 checks passed

This branch was successfully deployed

1 active deployment
Preview — 313eed2c Deployed Oct 16, 2026 by vercel[bot]
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant